Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
             16 January, 2021

Category:  Articles » Communications » Broadband Internet


Call It The 'Universal Slush Fund'

         Views: 1990
2010-10-14 08:29:27     
Article by Larry M. Elkin

The Universal Service Fund is a $7 billion federal program in search of a purpose.

Politicians and lawmakers don't know exactly what they want to do with the money they collect from millions of American telephone bills every year, but they know one thing: They don't want to stop collecting it. So they are bound and determined to find something to do with all that cash - probably something involving broadband, because broadband is strategic and cool and, well, everyone needs broadband.

The program, established in 1997, currently is used mainly to defray the cost of telephone service in rural areas, where the cost of providing service is higher due to greater distances between customers. This subsidy used $4.3 billion of the USF's total budget of $7.3 billion in 2009. The USF is also used to subsidize local telephone service for low-income people, to provide affordable high-tech communications services to rural health care providers, and to support Internet service providers that offer discounted rates to schools and libraries. All of these services are paid for by the funds raised from telephone companies, which in turn pass the costs on to consumers.

As criticism mounts over the fact that large telephone companies are the biggest beneficiaries of the USF (though if the point is to deliver vital services, it seems irrelevant that large companies are the ones delivering them), the Federal Communications Commission and Congress have both sought to reform the fund. Reform, however, does not appear to encompass the words "eliminate" or "reduce."(1)

Last winter the FCC suggested that some of the USF money going into the high-cost program should instead be used to subsidize broadband costs in rural areas. The recommendation was part of the FCC's National Broadband Plan, which seeks to dramatically increase the percentage of the population with high-speed Internet access.

In September the FCC released an Order and Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, seeking to force Sprint and Nextel to live up their 2008 commitments to give up universal service support, initially made in order to gain approval for a merger. In addition to pressuring compliance, the order asserted that the money would be used, not to support other companies providing telephone service in rural areas, but to increase funding for broadband programs.

The House Energy and Commerce Communications Subcommittee is now also considering diverting USF funds to broadband subsidies. The proposed Universal Service Reform Act of 2010 would require recipients of USF money to provide broadband service throughout the areas where they receive universal service support. The bill would also expand the types of companies required to pay into the USF to include Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) providers and all providers that offer network connections to the public. Despite the expansion of the contributor base, it is not surprising that broadband providers are largely in favor of the bill, while telephone service providers are primarily opposed.(2) Just as the large phone companies benefited by passing USF fees on to their customers and then collecting USF subsidies to deliver services, broadband providers hope to gain hordes of newly subsidized customers while transferring the costs to the existing client base.

Certainly access to communications systems, both 20th century and 21st century, is critical to economic success. And it is at least arguably true that, without subsidies, connectivity would be more expensive for residents of rural areas than for urban dwellers. (But I wish someone would explain why electricity and traditional telephone service cost me twice as much in densely populated suburban New York City as the rates at our vacation home in rural Vermont.)

Still, assuming communications costs are higher in the country, it does not necessarily follow that urban residents ought to be responsible for helping out those who are farther flung.

Every region has advantages and disadvantages that make some things cheaper and other things more expensive. In urban areas, for example, the same population density that makes telecommunications relatively cheap makes things like parking spaces relatively expensive. Nobody has suggested that rural Americans should kick in some money when they buy, register or fuel their cars so Manhattanites can park at rates comparable to those available in the country. If rural residents truly find the costs of unsubsidized telecommunications to be intolerably high, there is nothing to prevent them from moving to more populous regions.

The FCC argues that subsidies are necessary because the entire country suffers when large numbers of residents are cut off from communications. The FCC seems to be forgetting that prior to 1997, houses in the country did indeed have telephones, running on wires that were installed and paid for long before the USF was established. And, as Internet connection becomes increasingly indispensable, rural communities are responding by discovering the best ways to connect in their neck of the woods, whether that means relying on satellites or setting up their own fiber-based broadband services, as is being done in the region around my Vermont place.

The USF's use-it-don't-lose-it rationale is a great argument for sunset provisions and zero-based budgeting. Programs, especially subsidies and other cost-shifting mechanisms, ought to come with expiration dates that force legislators to periodically reconsider their effectiveness. Without this recurring assessment, programs that may no longer be beneficial are simply taken for granted; reforms may be offered up, but the possibility of elimination doesn't always make it to the table.

Programs that remain economically sensible, or even just politically popular (think "farm price supports") would be renewed, while outdated programs might at least sometimes get weeded out.

The USF program ought to be a target for legislative herbicide. But money helps careers grow like fertilizer in Washington, D.C., and those who control this pot of our cash are busy looking for new fields over which to spread it.


(1) The Hill: AT&T Collects The Most From FCC Fund

(2) The Hill: Rural Phone Providers To Make Case Against Overhaul of Universal Service Fund

For more articles, please visit the Palisades Hudson Financial Group LLC newsletter or subscribe to the blog.

Newsletter: http://palisadeshudson.com/sentinel/

Blog: http://palisadeshudson.com/current-commentary/

Specialized in: Asset Allocation - Investment Management - Personal Financial Planning - Financial Management Services - Tax Planning - Tax Return Preparation - Estate Planning - Insurance Consulting - Trust Design - Charitable Planning
URL: http://palisadeshudson.com/sentinel/
Print article      Bookmark this page
Related Articles 
How Can I Find Out Who Owns an Email Address? (Popularity: ): Threats and fear are the underlying factor why people conduct research to find out who owns an email address although the damages caused by this technological invention might not be publicized but we know that a lot of people are being scammed day in day out and so as not to be taken for a fool keep they their suffering innocence to themselves.Don't find yourself in this situation before you ...
Internet Safety For Kids - 4 Important Tips For Parents (Popularity: ): All around the globe, the Internet and computers have become indispensable. We communicate with friends, search for information, shop online, use online banking to pay our bills and many other things that make our lives easier. However, there are also certain dangers that come with Internet usage. Aside from viruses, the Internet could also pose threats to our children if they are allowed to use it without proper monitoring and ...
BSNL broadband (Popularity: ): BSNL is on the way of commissioning of a multi-gigabit, multi-protocol, a world class, convergent IP infrastructure with the help of national internet backbone, which will offer convergent services through the broadband access network. This BSNL broadband service can be available on DSK technology.BSNL broadband is one of the best broadband services of BSNL. This service is being offered on existing copper wire infrastructure. This service is known as the ...
Ethernet Or OC3 Bandwidth - What Do You Choose? (Popularity: ): Is Ethernet or OC3 bandwidth the right choice for a network solution for your business? How would you make that decision?If you are talking about a network operator / service provider and assuming your links are above 1 Gbps .... most likely you will need both OCx/EoS and Ethernet. After all you need to interconnect with other networks. If you have links below 1 Gbps at the access or core ...
Ordering An ADSL Line (Popularity: ): If you are in a situation where you think that you need to get a professionally fast and stable internet connection, then ADSL might be exactly what you are looking for.You'll find that having an internet connection that is both fast and efficient is something that you can turn to a great advantage when you are working and whether you are a large business or a small one, this is ...

Related Business 
Slush Ice Machine (Popularity: ): Slush ice is mixed in a special slush syrup and water. This mixture is filled into the slush machine. The slush machine freezes Trinkeis delicious. Slush ice is cheap to produce and there is no hygiene problem.
Slush Machine Hire (Popularity: ): Hire a slush machine that produces a slush of ice and liquid in the form of your favourite cocktail drink. We also provide impressive line up of flavours fun slush, fruit Slush, kids safe, isotonic, frappe, cocktail margarita.
Children Decide For Monster Slush (Popularity: ): Children love monster slush. The famous brand with the blue monster “Mikki” is the fast seller. Everybody knows the fruity fresh flavours with the many colors. Professionell advertising material like slush flag, advertising board for sidewalk, posters, advertising banners helps the customers to sale more. Become monster slush partner and earn easy money with premium quality.
OziSlush Slush Machines (Popularity: ): OziSlush Slush Machines is the market leader in providing premium quality Slush Granita Machines, Cocktail Machines, Catering Equipment & Related Supplies for home or business at an affordable price backed up by an Exclusive LifeTime Warranty. Easy to follow advice & the very highest level of quality and service.
Sigma Fund Sicav funds of hedge funds (Popularity: ): Luxembourg Sicav comprising three absolute return funds of hedge funds: Sigma Fund Universal, Sigma Fund Valencia and Sigma Fund Man. Attractive risk-adjusted returns with low correlation to traditional assets.
The Universal Law of Attraction (Popularity: ): Learn why the Universal law of attraction is the key to a success in all areas of your life. The Universal Law of Attraction discovering the real truth. When scientists look into their Hubble telescopes and peer out into vast blackness that we call outer space, they are constantly discovering new stars, planets and solar systems being created. This tells us one thing; Where there are things being created,the Universal ...
Jamestown Funds (Popularity: ): Relatively small fund family offers a balanced fund, an international fund, a domestic fund and a tax exempt (Virginia) fund.
HCAP Asset Management (Popularity: ): HCAP Asset Management, a specialist manager of high yield funds; fixed interest funds and hedge fund offerings. HCAP’s flagship offering is the HCAP Diversified Fund – an Asian focused high yield Fund with share classes denominated in USD and AUD. The Fund, substantially an active fixed interest fund by nature of many of its investments, looks to invest for both real and relative value. In doing so the Fund applies ...
Julian Lepa Law Office (Popularity: ): Julian Lepa Law Office is available for all legal steps necessary unlock or accelerate the process of settling your case if claims by the Fund shares. If you have received Property Fund shares before listing and you can not capitalize titles of compensation than the rate of approximately 45% (average trading price of the Fund's shares BSE), have reached the right place. Have your legal possibility to call the Romanian ...
Best Degree Certificate Apostille in Vadodara by ND universal (Popularity: ): Looking for degree certificate apostille in Vadodara? End of your search with ND Universal for all kinds of certificate apostille services, For more detail please call us on +919537089898.