Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
             30 October, 2020

Category:  Articles » Communications » Broadband Internet


Ethernet Or OC3 Bandwidth - What Do You Choose?

         Views: 2441
2008-10-18 08:35:00     
Article by Michael Lemm

Is Ethernet or OC3 bandwidth the right choice for a network solution for your business? How would you make that decision?

If you are talking about a network operator / service provider and assuming your links are above 1 Gbps .... most likely you will need both OCx/EoS and Ethernet. After all you need to interconnect with other networks. If you have links below 1 Gbps at the access or core sides of the network then you would have to use OCx, most likely. Although some people tend to say that for a new network you can do whatever you want, reality is another thing.

OCx/STM-N are known for their reliability and predictability and still have quite a good precense in long haul. These are migrating to EoS (VCAT, LCAS, GFP) and OTN but they won't satrt to become "pure" Ethernet until 43G and supposedly there won't be any difference at 100G so Ethernet could prevail adopting some of the reliability factors and DWDM compatibility from OTN. There is still long ways to go before the true convergence. In fact IEEE HSSG and ITU-T are working together to assure neither one reinvents each other's wheels. Perhaps, if they succed, we would see single physical interfaces that could handle both: Ethernet for end-to-end connectivity and OTN for transport applications.

If you are thinking forward, perhaps you need to add OTN and EoS to your transport/core infrastrucure so it is ready for the future and yet flexible to interconnect to other peers using OCx, or deliver services below 1 GigE using EoS. People claiming they get "pure Ethernet" from their providers may not be paying attention to the EoS add/drop box that was delivered with the service contract and it is in fact receiving packets and shooting OCx frames back to the central office, or it arrived at a near aggregation location via OCx/EoS and then radioes to the customer premisses (perhaps over an internal OCx link too).

Below 1 GigE rates (I believe) there is no good way to deliver Ethernet directly to the customer (access network). it always has to be wrapped on some sort of (unreliable) transport scheme like VDSL, SHDSL, DOCSIS,... This is (in my opinion) what's keeping SONET/SDH alive. Once we all have fiber and beyond 1GigE then there is no issue. You would be able to go Ethernet/OTN all the way.

While Ethernet is becoming quite widespread and cost effective, often times the A and Z locations may require a decision in favor of OC3. SONET being readily available, it may be more cost effective (yes - even including the WAN module for OC3) in some locations. For the same A and Z locations, if both Ethernet and OC3 are available, I would pick Ethernet due to the ease of integration as long as the cost is within ~ 65% of the OC3 circuit.

OCx has history, resilience, and capacity, and is subject to suppliers wringing every last cent out of it as an asset given the emergence of long(er) distance Ethernet.

"Choose wisely", says the Templar Knight in Indiana Jones and the Final Crusade... likewise here. Unless you are committed to a long-term contract on OCx, don't extend it unless your business and application requirements say you won't need Metro-E flexibility until the end of the extension period. Even then, negotiate for huge concessions and/or cost-free upgrade to Metro-E at the end. As cost competitiveness of a service is based on the amount of market share: Metro-e /10GB-e will dwarf OCx over time.

Lastly, choose OCx/Metro-E service based on achievable and measurable SLAs first ..... then nail the supplier to the floor on price (as you do .... or .... you should do).

Michael is the owner of FreedomFire Communications....including DS3-Bandwidth.com. Michael also authors Broadband Nation where you're always welcome to drop in and catch up on the latest BroadBand news, tips, insights, and ramblings for the masses.

Specialized in: Ethernet - Oc3 Bandwidth
URL: http://broadband-nation.blogspot.com
Print article      Bookmark this page
Related Articles 
Call It The 'Universal Slush Fund' (Popularity: ): The Universal Service Fund is a $7 billion federal program in search of a purpose.Politicians and lawmakers don't know exactly what they want to do with the money they collect from millions of American telephone bills every year, but they know one thing: They don't want to stop collecting it. So they are bound and determined to find something to do with all that cash - probably something involving broadband, ...
How Can I Find Out Who Owns an Email Address? (Popularity: ): Threats and fear are the underlying factor why people conduct research to find out who owns an email address although the damages caused by this technological invention might not be publicized but we know that a lot of people are being scammed day in day out and so as not to be taken for a fool keep they their suffering innocence to themselves.Don't find yourself in this situation before you ...
Broadband Media Allows Face to Face With Deployed Loved Ones (Popularity: ): Connecting with loved ones during the holidays is one joy that many Americans look forward to. Sometimes finances and schedules can be so tight that a holiday visit just isn't fated to happen on a given year, and sometimes, it helps to think outside the box, trying new ways to gain that precious holiday connectivity. This is where new innovations in broadband media technology and broadcasting can help fill in ...
Ordering An ADSL Line (Popularity: ): If you are in a situation where you think that you need to get a professionally fast and stable internet connection, then ADSL might be exactly what you are looking for.You'll find that having an internet connection that is both fast and efficient is something that you can turn to a great advantage when you are working and whether you are a large business or a small one, this is ...
The Four Broadband Baddies To Watch Out For (Popularity: ): There are four common problems that customers have during and after the broadband buying process. Here is a rundown on the four so hopefully you will not come a cropper to them.The first and most common problem is the set up fee. Also known as the installation or connection fee, and is the amount the broadband provider charges you for the activation of the service. The fee varies but can ...

Related Business 
Telco Solutions: Ethernet Over Copper (Popularity: ): Ethernet is the perfect solution for high bandwidth Internet access and/or providing Internet bandwidth for business voice VoIP/Hosted IP Voice requirements. We represent over thirty of the industry’s top carriers. As your broker, there is no charge for our services; we are paid a residual fee by the carrier. With our deep industry experience, we eliminate the confusion of self-serving sales pitches and too many choices and quickly zero in ...
Stat T1 OC3 Connection (Popularity: ): Offers dedicated T1, T3, OC3 and frame relay lines to customers nationwide.
Ethernet Cable (Popularity: ): Connect your PC or Mac to use high speed internet with an Ethernet cable for fast surfing. These cables are available at affordable prices and there are multiple colors and sizes to choose from.
AvaLAN Wireless Systems, Inc. (Popularity: ): Wireless Networking Products Manufacturer & Supplier - Buy online wireless products like wireless ethernet bridge, industrial ethernet products, wireless network camera, point-to-point wireless ethernet bridge, 900 mhz ethernet bridge, wireless antennas etc.
Bandwidth Monitor Pro - Monitor your Bandwidth (Popularity: ): Utility that displays and logs network adapters bandwidth usage. It supports logging of all network adapters at once and has a detailed transfer history. Product overview, screenshots, FAQs, and downloads.
Computer Bus Tools (Popularity: ): Test Solutions utilizing Ethernet Networks for-Gigabit Ethernet.
Allied Telesyn International (Popularity: ): Manufacturer of Ethernet, Fast Ethernet and gigabit networking components.
NETGEAR Small Business Networks (Popularity: ): Complete Fast Ethernet and gigabit Ethernet networking solutions.
Garrett Communications Ltd. (Popularity: ): For carrier class Ethernet, Fast Ethernet and Fibre Optic Switches, Hubs and media converters.
SMC Networks, Inc. (Popularity: ): Develops network interface cards, stackable, dual speed hubs and switches for ethernet and fast ethernet technologies.