Home Add to Favorite Contact Submit  
             29 March, 2024
 

    
Category:  Articles » Business » Marketing

 

What's Wrong with Focus Group Research?

Popularity:
         Views: 1612
2006-07-13 02:28:35     
Article by Jim Brackin

Since they were first used over 65 years ago by US government sociologists investigating the effectiveness of military propaganda movies the focus group has been the mainstay of the market research industry.

By the middle of the twentieth century, advertising agencies were jumping on the bandwagon hiring researchers to find out why certain kinds of products and services were appealing. The focus group gained popularity because its format prompted the participants to explain their reasons and motivations behind product attraction, recognition and ultimately purchase. The use of focus groups grew, especially amongst politicians as policy setting instruments. Focus groups even gained credence in academic research despite having no standard methodology for the gathering or capture of the outputs produced. It looked like the focus group was here to stay.

So what’s gone wrong? In his recent Slate Magazine article, "Lies, Damn Lies and Focus Groups?" Daniel Gross challenges the efficacy and value of focus groups for informing product development and marketing. He highlights the widely documented mismatch between what people say about product concepts in focus groups, and the way they actually behave when it comes to making purchases. This small difference costs companies millions in inappropriate product development and misguided advertising.

But more worryingly there is an increasing endemic problem with focus group research that simply refuses to go away. The ‘Focus Groupie’ is a term used to describe people who for whatever reason spend increasingly large amounts of their evenings contributing to focus groups. You can’t really blame them, the promise of £50 about $90 and a free meal is quite appealing. And nothing is sacred for these part-time professional opinion givers. Yesterday they were early adopting gin lovers, today cautious supporters of animal rights, tomorrow who knows? Yet, in the words of one such ‘focus groupie’ the only thing they have in common is that “after a while the stories don’t seem like lies – more like acting – and it’s quite fun to pretend to be someone you are not”

The industry is not laughing. In a recent issue of Research the magazine of the Market Research Society (UK) it was front page news. And it’s no fun for the clients who pay for this false and potentially misleading information. Torben Jessen, Saga’s Research Manager said that clients should be concerned about professional respondents, the fraudsters in particular because “The issue cuts to the credibility of research”.

A study into this problem carried out by BMRB between November 1999 and March 2000 found that; One in ten people who had taken part in a focus group within the previous 12 months had done so at least three times that year and one in 100 had 16 or more visits. That’s one focus group misled every three weeks. The only thing we know for sure is that the problem is getting worse not better. Liz Sykes, committee member of the UK’s Association for Qualitative Research commented “nobody really knows the scale of the problem”. Yet, whatever the scale, it’s the advertisers who pay for the research that are counting the cost. Not surprising then that many are now moving away from the old focus group model. It's lasted well, remember the focus group was developed when the bi-plane was still state of the art.

Perhaps it’s no surprise that a modern approach is increasing its market share dramatically. The use of online qualitative/quantitative research has doubled in the last three years. The reasons for this are obvious. It’s quick, cheap and by using in-house data, can tap into existing customers and prospects who have already undertaken the desired behaviour. Thus eliminating the 'focus groupie' fraudsters.

Many marketeers are using sophisticated psychometric models to help their understanding. Marketing a leading UK magazine reported recently that for Sainsbury’s Bank “Marketing consultancy ESP are running and analysing an online questionnaire included in the bank's monthly e-zine, which is e-mailed to the customer database. The bank wants to build a clearer picture of consumers' product purchasing behaviour, using psychographic data.” Surely this type of fast intelligent, ‘focus groupie’ free research is a good way forward. That is unless you are still happy donning your flying cap and climbing into your 65 year old bi-plane. Tally Ho! Chocks Away!

Print article      Bookmark this page
Related Articles 
How to Effectively Market your Product by Using Billboards Memphis (Popularity: ): Ever thought of marketing your business with billboards Memphis? Marketing your business with billboards can improve your business far more than you have imagined. It can entice more customers to patronize your goods and services. This was proven after some comments were made by marketers who have done so via different Memphis sign companies. Are you interested in marketing your products with billboards Memphis? If yes, this article is for ...
Modular industries furnishing companies in Verona can be of great help (Popularity: ): With increased ideas, concepts and facilities, the need for technology in our everyday lives is now great. This need increases tenfold in the workplace, where the execution of ideas with speed and precision is very important. For all these functions to be undertaken smoothly, we have become heavily dependent on technology, further increasing the need for gadgets like desktops, laptops, printers, monitors, fax machines etc. to be available always at ...
Key Strategies Required to Succeed in Food Marketing (Popularity: ): Succeeding food marketing requires efforts and special services. Advanced marketing services are required to reach to potential customers and achieve success. It is never easy for companies to create a bond with potential customer and allures to buy products. Nascent food companies face a serious challenge of building a worthy relationship that would help to promote products and convey special message of brand. A special relationship can be built by ...
Biomass Briquetting Machine in India is now available online (Popularity: ): Now-a-days some companies are coming up with efficient and environment friendly Biomass Briquetting Machine with an aim to preserve our nature. Biomass Briquetting Machine India has a vision to provide effective solutions for increasing demand for conventional fuels. This Briquetting Machine is being widely used in the agricultural sector and has proved to be helpful in preserving the nature.Briquetting Machine is mostly employed to convert waste gathered from agriculture, forestry ...
To Print Cartoon Images on PP Woven Bags Is Amazing (Popularity: ): PP woven bags are kind of reusable shopping bags which are surely the best buy today. Their popularity does not exist without reasons. Since they are reusable, they help save you cash and the most importantly, save the environment by keeping plastic waste away from the landfills. PP woven bags are sturdy. Therefore, they are capable of lasting for many months and even years. Usually things that last long and ...


Related Business 
Focus Group and Market Research Services (Popularity: ): Focus Groups and Qualitative Research methods used for product development, marketing communication, website development and customer satisfaction in the Information Technology, High Tech, Computer and Internet industries world wide.
FuelEvac - Help With Wrong Fuel (Popularity: ): If you have filled your car with the wrong fuel, don’t worry. Although having wrong fuel such as petrol in diesel engine would prevent your vehicle from starting up and could potentially damage the engine help is at hand. Your vehicle needs all the wrong fuel removed from the tank and the whole fuel system. This is where FuelEvac's fuel assist service comes in.
Online Market Research (Popularity: ): Eroberesearch.com is one of the best Online Market Research Company in all market Research Companies. Provides the Market Intelligence Research, Market Intelligence, Online Research Service. The Research provides the complete profile of the IT channel partners who matters the most including classification, turnover, product focus, vertical focus and wallet share.
Policy Research Associates (Popularity: ): Research group offering comprehensive services - applied research, policy analysis, evaluation studies, knowledge development and application, and technical assistance - with a primary focus on mental health services.
Wrong Fuel Recovery (Popularity: ): Wrong Fuel Recovery, the home of mobile fuel draining. If you have put the wrong fuel in your car or van's fuel tank, we offer a fully mobile and cost effective way to get you back on the road again in the shortest possible time. We concentrate on customer experience and satisfaction to make this ordeal as easy and less stressful as possible for you.
Caltech Parallel and Distributed Computing Group (Popularity: ): Research group at California Institute of Technology. Focus includes fault-tolerant cluster computing.
Agroforestry Research Trust (Popularity: ): English nonprofit group conducts research into temperate agroforestry and into all aspects of plant cropping and uses, with a focus on tree, shrub and perennial crops.
Dodge Business Research Consulting (Popularity: ): Integrated market research solutions for business decision-makers. Focus Group moderating and quantitative market research in business to business and consumer segments. World-wide capabilities and experience.
Groups Plus, Inc. (Popularity: ): Focus group research by Tom Greenbaum's organization.
Cid Gallup (Popularity: ): Offers market research, survey research, public opinion polls, telephone interview, focus group and other market analysis tools throughout Latin America. [English/Spanish]